Free shipping on orders above €299.00

We independently select all products and services. If you click through links we provide, Far & Away may earn a commission with no extra cost to you.

Best Martini Olives

Top 5 Best Martini Olives in 2024

The martini, a beloved classic cocktail, owes its uniqueness to the olive, an essential ingredient. The olive in a martini contributes a savory and salty taste that pairs perfectly with the gin or vodka. That being said, not all olives are the same, so selecting the ideal ones can significantly enhance your martini enjoyment.

When it comes to selecting the best martini olives, there are a few critical factors to consider. First and foremost, you want to look for olives that are firm and meaty, as they will hold up better in the drink and provide a satisfying texture. Additionally, you want to choose olives that are flavorful and not overly salty, as they can overpower the drink and make it unenjoyable.

Another important consideration is the type of olive. While green olives are the most common choice for martinis, there are also black olives and stuffed olives to choose from. Each type has its own unique flavor profile, so it’s worth exploring your options to find the perfect fit for your taste preferences.

At the end of the day, the best martini olives are the ones that enhance the overall experience of the cocktail. Whether you prefer classic green olives or something more adventurous like blue cheese-stuffed olives, choosing high-quality olives will elevate your martini to the next level. In the next section, we will review some of the top martini olives on the market to help you make an informed decision.

Best Martini Olives

We all know that the perfect martini requires the perfect olive. That’s why we’ve scoured the market to bring you the best of the best martini olives. Whether you prefer your olives stuffed with blue cheese or garlic, we’ve got you covered. Here are our top picks for the best martini olives on the market.

Santa Barbara Olive Co Pimento Martini Olives

If you are looking for a high-quality martini olive, Santa Barbara Olive Co Pimento Martini Olives are a great choice. These olives are perfect for anyone who wants to take their martini game to the next level.

Pros

  • Hand-stuffed with pimento for a delicious flavor
  • High-quality olives that are perfect in shape, color and size
  • Unmatched attention to detail throughout the harvest process

Cons

  • Slightly more expensive than other martini olive options
  • Some customers have reported issues with broken jars during shipping
  • Not suitable for those who do not enjoy the taste of olives

These olives are hand-stuffed with pimento, which brings out a deliciously tart flavor that is perfect for martinis. Santa Barbara Olive Co has a long tradition dating back to 1850 of providing the finest gourmet olives on the market, and these martini olives are no exception.

The attention that Santa Barbara Olive Co pays to each olive throughout its harvest ensures the unique, high-quality taste of the Santa Barbara Olive Co olive. Their olive selection process demands that each olive is perfect in shape, color and size.

While these olives are slightly more expensive than other martini olive options, the quality and taste is well worth the extra cost. However, some customers have reported issues with broken jars during shipping, so it is important to handle the jars with care upon arrival.

Overall, if you are looking for a high-quality martini olive that is sure to impress, Santa Barbara Olive Co Pimento Martini Olives are an excellent choice.

Campo D’Oro Sicilian Pitted Green Olives In Brine

If you’re looking for a unique and authentic martini olive, then Campo D’Oro Sicilian Pitted Green Olives In Brine is worth trying.

Pros

  • These olives are authentic Sicilian products, made with traditional artisan methods that reflect the Sicilian culinary tradition.
  • The olives are vacuum packed in a glass jar, ensuring maximum quality and freshness.
  • The olives have a beautiful green color and a mild salty flavor, making them a perfect accompaniment to a pre-dinner drink or to garnish an imaginative salad.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported that the olives are too soft or mushy, which may not be to everyone’s taste.
  • The price point is higher than some other martini olive options on the market.
  • The olives may not be suitable for those with a strong aversion to salty flavors.

We were pleasantly surprised by the quality and flavor of these olives. They’re a unique addition to any martini or cocktail and have a distinct flavor that sets them apart from other olives on the market. The vacuum-packed glass jar ensures that the olives are fresh and of high quality.

While the olives may be too soft for some, we found that they had a pleasant texture that paired well with the mild salty flavor. They’re also versatile and can be used to add an extra bite to a meat or fish dish, or to decorate a pizza.

Overall, if you’re looking for an authentic and unique martini olive option, then Campo D’Oro Sicilian Pitted Green Olives In Brine is definitely worth trying.

Calivirgin Dirty Martini Mix

If you’re looking to take your martinis to the next level, Calivirgin Dirty Martini Mix is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • Elevates the taste of your martini with premium, certified organic olives grown on a California ranch
  • Handpicked and hand-pressed olives ensure maximum flavor extraction
  • No preservatives or chemicals, just 100% pure, naturally salt-cured organic olive brine

Cons

  • Some may find the price point a bit high compared to other options
  • The flavor may be too strong for those who prefer a milder martini
  • The bottle size may not be suitable for frequent martini drinkers

If you’re looking for a high-quality dirty martini mix, Calivirgin is a great choice. The certified organic olives and hand-pressed extraction process make for a uniquely flavorful martini experience.

The mix is made with nothing but pure, naturally salt-cured organic olive brine, so you can enjoy your drink without any added preservatives or chemicals.

While the price point may be higher than other options, the quality of the product justifies the cost. However, those who prefer a milder martini may find the flavor a bit too strong.

The bottle size is also something to consider, as frequent martini drinkers may need to purchase multiple bottles. Overall, if you’re looking for a high-quality, all-natural dirty martini mix, Calivirgin is definitely worth a try.

Collins Pitted Olives Popular Garnish for Cocktails

If you’re looking for an all-natural, premium option for your cocktails, Collins Pitted Olives are a great choice. They’re perfect for adding authenticity and extra flavor to your favorite cocktails.

Pros

  • These olives are pitted, which means they are ready to use straight from the jar, making them a convenient option for cocktail garnishes or salads.
  • With a bold and salty taste, these olives are a great way to ramp up the authenticity of your cocktails.
  • These olives are a tasty snack that’s ready-to-eat straight from the jar, making them a great addition to any meze or Mediterranean salad.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported that the olives are overly salty and almost not edible.
  • A few customers have reported that the olives taste off or have little to no cheese.
  • A small number of customers have reported that the olives arrived with the cap open and the olives all over the box.

We highly recommend Collins Pitted Olives for anyone looking for a premium option for their cocktails. These olives are a great way to add an extra burst of flavor to your drinks, and they’re also a tasty snack on their own. Whether you’re a professional bartender or just looking to impress your friends with your mixology skills, these olives are a must-have in your bar.

Filthy Cocktail Garnish, Pimento Stuffed Olives

If you’re in search of the perfect martini olive, Filthy Cocktail Garnish’s Pimento Stuffed Olives are definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • These olives are packed with flavor, making them a great addition to any cocktail.
  • Made from high-quality ingredients, these olives are non-GMO, vegan, and gluten-free.
  • The sleek glass jar makes for a great addition to any at-home bar.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported issues with the packaging, with jars arriving cracked or damaged.
  • These olives are a bit on the expensive side compared to other options on the market.
  • The jar size is smaller than some customers were expecting.

These olives are naturally cured and hand-stuffed with Spanish pimento peppers, making them a great way to elevate your martini or Bloody Mary. The olive brine is oil-free, ensuring that the olives are not overly greasy or oily.

One of the standout features of these olives is their flavor. They are packed with taste, making them a great addition to any cocktail. The pimento peppers add a nice touch of spice, without being too overpowering.

In addition to their great taste, these olives are made from high-quality ingredients. They are non-GMO, vegan, and gluten-free, making them a great option for those with dietary restrictions.

The sleek glass jar that these olives come in is also a great feature. It makes for a great addition to any at-home bar and is the perfect size for those who are just starting to build their cocktail collection.

While there are some drawbacks to these olives, such as the higher price point and smaller jar size, overall they are a great option for those who are serious about their cocktails. If you’re looking for a high-quality martini olive that is packed with flavor, Filthy Cocktail Garnish’s Pimento Stuffed Olives are definitely worth considering.

Buying Guide

When it comes to selecting the best martini olives, there are a few key features to consider. Here are some factors to keep in mind when making your purchase:

Olive Type

There are many types of olives available on the market, but not all of them are suitable for use in a martini. Generally, green olives are preferred over black olives due to their milder taste and firmer texture. Some popular types of green olives for martinis include Spanish Queen, Picholine, and Castelvetrano.

Stuffing Options

While traditional martini olives are simply brine-cured, many modern variations come stuffed with a variety of fillings. Popular stuffing options include blue cheese, garlic, jalapeño, and pimento. Consider your personal taste preferences when selecting a stuffing option.

Brine Quality

The brine used to cure the olives can greatly affect their taste and texture. Look for olives that have been cured in a high-quality brine made from natural ingredients. Avoid olives that have been cured in overly salty brine, as this can overpower the taste of the martini.

Packaging

Martini olives are typically sold in jars or cans. Opt for a package that is easy to open and resealable to keep your olives fresh. Additionally, consider the size of the package based on your martini-making needs.

By considering these factors, you can ensure that you select the best martini olives for your cocktail.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of olives enhance the flavor of a gin martini?

When it comes to gin martinis, we recommend using green olives, specifically those that are brined in dry vermouth. These olives complement the botanical notes in gin, resulting in a balanced and flavorful martini.

Are pimento-stuffed olives recommended for martinis?

While pimento-stuffed olives are a popular choice for martinis, we suggest avoiding them. The pimento can overpower the delicate flavors of the gin and vermouth, resulting in a less enjoyable drinking experience.

Which olive brine is preferred for crafting a dirty martini?

For a classic dirty martini, we suggest using the brine from Spanish Queen Olives. This brine has a tangy and slightly salty flavor that pairs well with gin and vermouth, while also adding a subtle olive flavor to the cocktail.

How do Spanish Queen Olives impact a martini’s taste profile?

Spanish Queen Olives are known for their meaty texture and bold flavor. When used in a martini, they add a subtle olive flavor that complements the botanical notes in gin and vermouth. Additionally, the brine from these olives can be used to create a delicious dirty martini.

What are the characteristics of gourmet olives suitable for martinis?

Gourmet olives suitable for martinis should have a firm texture and a balanced flavor. Look for olives that are brined in dry vermouth or have a subtle olive flavor. Avoid olives with overpowering flavors or textures that can detract from the overall drinking experience.

How many olives should traditionally be used when serving a martini?

Traditionally, martinis are served with one or two olives. However, the number of olives used can vary depending on personal preference. Some people prefer their martinis with a single olive, while others enjoy a garnish of three or more olives.

Share

Leave a Comment